Why are medial meniscus tears more common?

Why are medial meniscus tears more common?

London Cartilage Clinic

Written By London Cartilage Clinic

Oftentimes, when someone suffers a meniscus tear it’s usually a medial tear as opposed to a lateral tear. Why is this? And more importantly, what’s the difference between the two? This post is designed to give you an insight into meniscus tears and what can cause them. The hope is that you’ll be able to make an informed decision as to whether meniscus tear surgery is right for you. 

What is a medial meniscus tear? 

The medial meniscus is located on the inside of the knee between the tibia and femur, whereas the lateral meniscus sits outside the knee. The anterior cruciate ligament and patella are further out from both menisci. Their intended function is to cushion the knee joint, protect the bones, and allow the bone ends to pass over each other. 

When the medial meniscus tears, it will lead to a complete or incomplete break in the structure. Symptoms will vary from person to person and can include: 

  • Swelling. 
  • Pain localised to the inside or back of the knee joint. 
  • A knee that can’t be fully extended or bent. 
  • A limp. 
  • Catching or occasional locking of the knee. 

Contributing factors in medial meniscus tears 

 Nowadays, it is accepted in the medical field that tears in meniscus cartilage is a common source of knee discomfort and disability. The following are the main of the factors that can contribute either directly or indirectly to a tear in the medial meniscus.

As discussed earlier, the medial meniscus is attached to the interior of the knee joint and the medial collateral ligament. This makes it far more rigid and prone to tearing under the stress of certain forces.

The shape of the medial meniscus compared to the lateral could also be a factor. The former has a steeper curvature, meaning that forces could be concentrated more heavily on the medial meniscus during strenuous knee movements.

When we put weight on our legs, a majority of the weight is transferred through the medial section of the knee. This force is vastly increased during running, as especially when landing from a jump. As we put weight on our knees on a daily basis, it means the medial meniscus is more likely to experience wear and tear. Over time, this causes a weakening of the meniscus that increases the chances of a tear.

People who do regular exercise are more prone to bone and soft tissue injuries such as fractures and cartilage tears. This typically occurs when the leg is planted but an impact causes the knee joint to rotate or twist suddenly. The medial meniscus has a lower range of motion than the lateral meniscus, which is why dynamic movements are more likely to damage it. Certain sports will put individuals more at risk of a meniscus tear than others.

A tight ligament can place more stress on the soft tissue in and around joints. The medial collateral ligament (MCL) which runs along the back of the knee is the one that can impact the medial meniscus. Its function is to limit extreme lateral movements and provide stability to the knee.

Age is a factor in increasing the likelihood of both medial and lateral meniscus tears. This is because the meniscus can naturally deteriorate over time, becoming weaker and less elastic. The result is that even minor falls and impacts can cause the menisci to be damaged.

Healing from a medial meniscus tear 

Complex or severe tears to the medial meniscus are highly detrimental as they can prevent regular leg movement and cause pain. In these cases, an arthroscopy procedure is required for meniscus repair or replacement. Meniscus tear surgery is proven to be effective at restoring the protective function of the meniscus within the knee joint. The nature of the surgery will change slightly depending on the type of tear and its location. As a result, patient recovery times will always vary post operation. That being said, a partial meniscus repair will most often have faster rehabilitation. 

 Small meniscus tears can usually be treated through non-operative methods. To prevent further injury, a medical professional will likely recommend avoiding physical activities and the use of a knee brace. Do note that minor tears don’t always display symptoms immediately. 

A clinic that cares 

At London Cartilage Clinic, our primary objective is providing patients with positive outcomes. This means focusing on quality of experience as well as results. Book a free chat using the form on our website to speak with a friendly member of the team about our range of specialist treatments. No one should have to feel as though they are stuck waiting to be seen, all while they’re in pain and unable to move freely. 

Book a Consultation

Book a free chat

We can help!

If you’re looking for support with effective cartilage treatment, our specialists can help. Fill in your details below and a member of our team will get in touch with you as soon as possible.