Is Microfracture Surgery Right for You? Understanding the Pros, Cons, and Alternatives

Is Microfracture Surgery Right for You? Understanding the Pros, Cons, and Alternatives

London Cartilage Clinic

Written By London Cartilage Clinic

In the realm of orthopaedic care and sports medicine, microfracture surgery has been a topic of much discussion. Particularly favoured for treating damaged articular cartilage in knees, it holds a beacon of hope for athletes and active individuals alike. However, as with any medical procedure, it’s crucial to dive deep into what it entails, its efficacy, and how it stacks up against alternative treatments. This article aims to demystify microfracture surgery, providing you with the insights needed to make an informed decision on your journey to recovery.

Understanding Microfracture Surgery

Microfracture surgery is a technique designed to address damaged cartilage, primarily in the knee joint. The procedure involves creating tiny fractures in the bone beneath the damaged cartilage. These fractures encourage the body to initiate a healing response, producing new cartilage tissue. Initially, microfracture surgery showed promise, especially for athletes seeking to return to their sports. However, the long-term effectiveness of this procedure has been a subject of debate within the medical community.

The Drawbacks of Microfracture Surgery

While the short-term outcomes can be encouraging, studies and clinical experiences suggest that the success of microfracture surgery may wane over time. The core challenge lies in the nature of the cartilage repair process. The newly formed tissue, often referred to as “fibrocartilage,” differs from the original articular cartilage in both structure and durability. Consequently, patients may experience a recurrence of pain and decreased joint function as the repair tissue deteriorates, especially under the continued stress of high-impact activities.

Exploring Alternatives for Cartilage Repair

Given the limitations of microfracture surgery, the orthopaedic field has been fervently exploring alternative treatments. These include:

  • Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation (ACI): A procedure where a patient’s own cartilage cells are harvested, cultured, and then re-implanted into the damaged area. Though promising, ACI can be associated with a significant reoperation rate.
  • Mosaicplasty: This technique involves transferring healthy cartilage from a non-weight-bearing area of the joint to the damaged site. Mosaicplasty has shown to be effective, particularly in younger patients or those with smaller lesions.
  • Mesenchymal Stromal Cells (MSCs): The use of MSCs is an emerging field, focusing on regenerative medicine’s potential to repair or replace damaged tissues. These cells are being studied for their ability to support the repair of articular cartilage defects and improve underlying bone conditions.

Making the Right Choice

Deciding on the appropriate treatment requires a comprehensive evaluation of your specific condition, lifestyle, and long-term health goals. Factors such as the extent of cartilage damage, age, activity level, and overall joint health play a crucial role in determining the most suitable approach.


FAQs on Microfracture Surgery and Alternatives

The long-term effectiveness can diminish over time, mainly due to the difference in durability and structure of the newly formed tissue compared to the original cartilage.

Alternatives include Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation (ACI), mosaicplasty, and the use of Mesenchymal Stromal Cells (MSCs), each with its own set of advantages and considerations.

ACI shows promise in creating a more durable repair tissue, although it comes with a higher risk of reoperation.

Mosaicplasty may offer more lasting results in suitable candidates, particularly those with smaller areas of damage and younger patients.

While some patients experience initial improvement, the long-term durability of the repair tissue can lead to a recurrence of symptoms over time.

Stem cell therapy is a burgeoning field, offering potential new avenues for effectively repairing cartilage damage.

Cartilage Repair Specialists

Choosing the right path for cartilage repair is a journey best navigated with comprehensive information and guidance from trusted medical professionals. At London Cartilage Clinic, we’re committed to providing our patients with the knowledge and care necessary to make informed decisions about their treatment options, prioritising long-term joint health and mobility.

Book a consultation


Book a free chat

We can help!

If you’re looking for support with effective cartilage treatment, our specialists can help. Fill in your details below and a member of our team will get in touch with you as soon as possible.